Liverpool’s record-breaking summer arrival, Florian Wirtz, is under fire from fans, pundits, and former players alike. Since joining from Bayer Leverkusen for around £116 million, the 22-year-old has failed to deliver the immediate impact many expected. But do the criticisms hold up, or is he simply in a transitional phase?
🔍 What’s Going On With Wirtz
- No Goals or Assists So Far: Through his first eight or nine appearances for Liverpool, Wirtz has yet to register a goal or assist. He did provide an assist in the Community Shield, but in the Premier League and Champions League so far, his influence in the final third has been minimal.
- Unfamiliar Roles and Positioning: Critics argue Wirtz hasn’t been used in his preferred attacking midfield positions full-time. Instead, Liverpool have deployed him in deeper or wider roles, which may not play to his strengths. Some pundits claim he’s “shoehorned” into systems that limit his effect.
- Physical Demands & Adaptation: England’s Premier League is more physical and faster in tempo than the Bundesliga, something Wirtz himself has acknowledged. He has spoken about being under less protection than he felt in Germany, suggesting he needs time to adjust to challenges such as tight marking, heavy pressing, and constant transitions.
🗣 Voices in the Debate
- TalkSPORT / Fan Criticism: Some fans have gone as far as calling him “the worst signing in Premier League history,” citing the huge price tag and the lack of tangible returns.
- Wayne Rooney & Other Pundits: Ex-players like Rooney have questioned whether Wirtz fits into Liverpool’s current setup, suggesting there may be too many players in attacking positions and that role clarity is needed for him to shine.
- Support for Patience: Others, including ex Reds players and pundits, have urged calm, stating that a player of his profile and age needs adjustment time. They cite examples of players who needed months or even a full season before hitting full form after big moves.
⚽ Why It Might Be Too Soon to Judge Harshly
- Big Price ≠ Instant Success: The £116M fee naturally raises expectations. But historically, many expensive signings take time to adjust. Pressure can hamper performance early.
- System & Team Needs Time: Liverpool under new management are still settling into their style. When the entire squad is adjusting, chances are certain players will lag behind early.
- Glimpses of Talent: Despite the lack of goal contributions, there have been flashes of quality. His ability to carry the ball, find pockets between the lines (when given time), and his positional awareness still show the technical level that made Liverpool pursue him.
Leave a comment